(1955): Their first national #1 hit, written by manager Buck Ram.

(1958): A lush cover of the Jerome Kern standard that reached #1 on the Billboard Hot 100.

Can you tell me or provide any lyrics you remember so I can help identify the correct song? Rare Songs - Album by The Platters | Spotify

: While "Rare Songs" collections exist, "O'l Bignù" is not listed among standard "rare" tracks such as "Bark, Battle and Ball" or "Heaven on Earth". Confirmed Major Hits by The Platters